Skip to main content

Liberty and Justice for All

I have been struck this morning by something that seems so simple now that I see it, and I am sure I'm not the first to have realized it.  Journalists of many stripes have taken to referring to the actions of some NFL athletes as "anthem protests".  That is, quite simply, inaccurate. 

The taking of a knee during the national anthem is not to protest the national anthem, rather it is to protest police brutality against minorities.  It just so happens that it is taking place during the national anthem.  Imagine if we referred to people who were evacuating before Irma as "fleeing to get away from their homes."  That, too, would be inaccurate.  They were evacuating to escape the dangers presented by the wind and rain that were coming with the storm.  They were doing what was necessary to protect themselves.  To refer to their actions as a flight to leave their homes and get away from their lives and belongings would be silly, because it's inaccurate.

The same can be said about referring to football players taking a knee during the national anthem as "anthem protests."

The problem that arises is an incorrect understanding by people who don't, or won't, dissect the semantics of the situation to get behind the catchy phrase.  They are then upset that people would protest the flag, which is not what is being protested.  In some cases this leads to racial divides, partisan divides, and patriotism divides. 

When referred to as "anthem protests" there is an interpretation by some that these men are being unpatriotic and disrespectful of the flag, the national anthem, and of what this country stands for.  In reality, they are acting in a way that is striving for the very heart of what the United States of America stands for.  They are pointing out an injustice and trying to help the country talk about it, change it, and become a nation that is, at long last, a nation "with liberty and justice for all."

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Where's your heart?

I was flying recently and as we were banking during the initial ascent I was able to look out of the window at the city with its skyscraper-abundant skyline getting further and further away.  Suddenly a suburb came into view and I noticed that the tallest structure was unmistakably a church steeple and was reminded of something I read years ago.  I don't remember who wrote it, but the gist of it went something like this: The Gospel of Matthew tells us "where your treasure is, there will your heart be, also."  For centuries before the Industrial Revolution, the largest building in any city or town would have most likely been the church.  It was the central meeting place.  The citizens came together and gave their money to build large, beautiful churches, edifices to stand as a testament to the importance of that faith in their lives.  The people might not have had much, but they spent their treasure to build those churches because it was so important to th...
Post a Comment
Read more

Fine Motor Skills

Take a look at  President Trump signing some documents  and see if you see what I see. When I watch our president sign his name, I see a man moving his arm back and forth with some significant, and unnecessary, fervor.  I realize that the D, l, d, J, and T are tall letters, but I have some tall letters in my name, too, and I don't have near that much arm movement in my signature.  I also sign my name relatively large, and yet most of my writing is finger movement, not arm movement. I acknowledge that I might be making too much of this, but they say you can tell a great deal about a person by their signature. Watching this large movement, where small movements suffice, makes me think of his over-sized aggression towards Hillary Clinton (and his Republican opponents before her) during the campaign.  I think of his huge, bold statements about walls, health care coverage, restoring America's greatness, his superior knowledge of things military, and so much mor...
Post a Comment
Read more